Thursday, July 23, 2009

Clearwire is on Tract for Funding of Nationwide WiMAX Deployment

Some criticism has been leveled at Clearwire's business plan: it is said that the capital obtained in the partnership restructuring is not sufficient to achieve the planned deployment coverage and that more funding will cause dilution of the current shareholders. This idea is way out of line.  Of course more funding will be needed, that has always been the case as nationwide deployments typically range from $20-$30 billion. WiMAX portends to be much lower in cost to achieve similar coverage at much higher bandwidth than compared to 3-3.5G mobile networks. 

Funding would only have become an issue if the underlying business model was not robust.  Many financial and industry analysts simply did not get it because they had become so well trained by past success that it had clouded their judgments or they simply didn't do the bottom-up construct of the technology and business development.

I've encountered this entrenched line of thinking from both the mobile industry and the IT industry for several years: The Mobile industry has prided itself for the stupendous success of mobile phone proliferation.  But a major part of that success was simply capitalizing on 3 basic things: the human nature need and desire for people to talk their heads off, the Moore's Law enabling capabilities of silicon circuits, and the ability to harness those by providing small battery powered devices that did a very simple thing - allowed people to talk while they were mobile.  This took both highly devoted, brilliant people to make it such a success, but also channeling of capital and development in very constrained ways that has led to very little true technology innovation beyond mobility itself.

I keep hitting on this point: Think about what is on the best SmartPhones the leaders of the mobile industry have produced.  I know and respect many people in the mobile industry and will spend more time this summer visiting with them at their expense.  Maybe what I have to say to them shows they want to listen to other than their own 'yes men'. part of what I have had to say is where has innovation stem from?  I've pointed to all the basic things you find on your wonderful mobile phones and, behold, the innovation that created almost all of them came from IT, web, and software specific industries.

Intel's CEO had said some time back that "perceptions will change once products get into people's hands".  WiMAX products have taken some time getting into a stage where they innovation fuels upon itself.  And now there appears to be some threat, and very much the image of a threat, coming from the 3G industry that LTE will simply displace WiMAX.

Think about that for a minute: some of the same arrogance led to statements about the impact of the iPhone: "We are going on 3 billion mobile subscribers (now closer to 4), what do we care what that PC industry company introduces?"  Believe me, some people in the mobile industry openly scoffed at the prospects for the iPhone "Maybe they will capture 3% and then find out they can't make any money competing with us".

The problem with major paradigm shifts is few see them coming or, if they do, are willing to rock their own boat on the sea of current industry success to change the course that they are on.

Think about WiMAX.. what the heck is it anyway?  It is a new 'framework of technologies', indeed a new way to look at how to build a wireless system that takes where 3G had evolved to but starts with a fresh sheet of paper to build in IP, multiple channel organization in the frequency domain, smart antenna methods, and common with IT, Smart/Intelligent netowrking methods.

Then ask 'What the heck is LTE':  ditto, ditto, ditto... except it is not able to so completely start with a clean slate because it has to wedge into incumbent networks and business practices while the diverse operators, country regulators (sometimes outright dictators) decide how to impose their wills on what big and small users take advantage of all the mumbo-jumbo slang of technology.

I admit to being a technology nerd... sometimes I actually like to sit down for many hours until my eyes bug out doing quick searches and scans of patents... I use software tools that let me find 100s at a time from around the world and dissect and categorize them in a semi-automated fashion otherwise it would be impossible.  But that process also leads to an understanding of what is developing for the next 2-3 iterations of the standards and commercial networks.  Much of what we see now is 'hurry up and wait'.

0 Comments:

Post a Comment

<< Home