Wednesday, August 26, 2009

The WiMAX Enigma

Recent news that WiMAX vendor Alvarion posted a US$4 million net loss for Q2 2009 and that CEO Tzvika Friedman is stepping down shows that Alvarion is not an exception to what we have observed elsewhere. Some things to keep in mind:
Most equipment vendors have been hit hard by the recession, and equipment investments represent for operators only a small fraction of service revenues.

This of course, is front-end loaded – networks must be built before they generate revenues. However, the long-term projections should trend to the norm for CAPEX, which means that spending on infrastructure will increasingly be funded internally. As revenues rise network build-outs become correspondingly larger and more costly but also shift to services that run on top of the network such as IPTV and VoIP. Alvarion has blamed many of its problems on the economy: trouble getting projects financed, etc., and this is certainly a factor. But the few WiMAX vendors make admission about the attractiveness of LTE as a factor in delaying decisions.

Arguments can be made that WiMAX is already here and is affordable because it is unburdened by legacy networks and other costs such as higher IPR. However, because WiMAX has been slow to develop mass markets, including the attractive mobile devices needed to drive consumers, markets remain relatively under-developed. For instance, India/BSNL has continued to delay a major WiMAX push. USB dongles and embedded modules have come down in price to levels that officials in India had said would make more extensive deployments possible. The continued delays beg the question as to whether LTE is being reconsidered as an option.

Here is the enigma: WiMAX is experiencing rapid growth. We measure a year-over-year growth rate of about 75% – good for such tough economic circumstances. So why are WiMAX vendors not seeing similarly rapid growth? The reason is that the many suppliers are soaking it up. Tier 1s are more behind LTE because that is where the majority of incumbent money is flowing.

The other part of the equation is that WiMAX is just recently seeing mobile devices become available, such as netbooks, notebooks and dongles. The really attractive mobile devices are still in the pipeline and we don't yet see them being certified by the WiMAX Forum, or available for mass-market networks like Clearwire’s. Where are the UMDs and SmartPhone devices whose arrival Intel has long touted? We have seen the demo devices but they are not appearing as certified devices on the WiMAX Forum list, and are not available in the market. If you compare the market dynamics of WiMAX to those of mobile services, the “hot” devices tied to apps stores and services are driving a large portion of subscriber growth, revenues and ARPU increases. WiMAX may be well suited to underserved markets, but there is still a need for a comparable subscriber growth driver. Where are the hot devices and business concepts? What can the kiosk-to-user model achieve? Does the availability of low cost dongles drive subscriber growth? Apparently not.

The problem with rural markets is they are not ready for heavy saturation since they lack exposure to these types of technologies; so new needs and demands have yet to develop in order to drive significant market growth. Mobile voice and messaging, on the other hand, are easily incorporated into everyday modes of communication, and have immediate social and productivity benefits. Mobile phones continue to proliferate in rural areas at a rapid pace despite the economy: rural expansion in China and India continues.

Did it ever make sense for WiMAX to ignore the mobile equation? There isn't a simple answer because there is no single market segment that is likely to make or break the case for WiMAX. Rather, it has to grow based on its ability to serve many markets, be more open to innovation, and have low barriers to participation including within developing countries.

Overall, WiMAX vendors – especially the smaller ones – are suffering, and are vulnerable to changes in the economy and other variables including increased competition coming from LTE (which we should see kick in by late next year). How do WiMAX vendors position themselves as the broadband overlay suppliers? How does the ecosystem get the message across more effectively that WiMAX will evolve into a network that can be used in combination with 3G, for a lower cost? How does can WiMAX vendors better position themselves as enablers of the "4G Cloud" that is friendly to the computing industry? What strategies should the WiMAX Forum be promoting? Strategically, there is much that can still be put into place; winnable positions may be lacking but companies like Alvarion, and the WiMAX ecosystem in general, must act to help assure their future.

For more information you can contact the author at robert@maravedis-bwa.com

Labels: , , , , ,

Google Voice on the iPhone: Front and Center in the Open Networks Clash of the Titans

The issue of how openness of networks should be defined by regulators, suppliers and operators has once again come into focus as the FCC considers complaints by Google that Apple has restricted Google Voice from being available for the iPhone. AT&T has responded that they have not stipulated that Google Voice or other applications cannot run on their network so long as they adhere to security and service agreement requirements. (see ATT's response letter to the FCC Google Voice inquiry):

FCC, "Question 1(a). What role, if any, did AT&T play in Apple’s consideration of the Google Voice and related applications?"
AT&T, "AT&T had no role in Apple’s consideration of Google Voice or related applications."

Apple's response is that they have not made a decision yet. But they say that Google Voice imposes a user interface that is different than the iPhone and that it replaces core voice telephone capability:

"FCC, Question 1a. Why did Apple reject the Google Voice application for iPhone and remove related third-party applications from its App Store?"

Apple, "Contrary to published reports, Apple has not rejected the Google Voice application, and continues to study it. The application has not been approved because, as submitted for review, it appears to alter the iPhone’s distinctive user experience by replacing the iPhone’s core mobile telephone functionality and Apple user interface with its own user interface for telephone calls, text messaging and voicemail."

This argument hinges on the operative word 'replaces' and can be attuned to imposition of an application in the PC environment. While the mobile and PC environments have been distinct in the past, this is not necessarily the world we all live in today.

From my understanding of how Google Voice works on the iPhone it is as an individual application chosen by the user from among others. As such, to say that it replaces the telephone capabilities of the iPhone is an overreaching attempt at exclusion. That is like saying "we have a fair and open applications environment so long as you don't compete with our core applications." If that is the case, given the shape of the delivery model and prior FCC rulings, I don't think that this argument will stick. In the least, the FCC is likely to require Apple to set guidelines for what constitutes 'replacement' of their core interface and apps and then allow Google and others to be given the opportunity to use the interface at user's discretion. Its speculative but my guess is 90% odds Google will prevail on being able to be offered as app that runs on the iPhone. Perhaps after some modifications. Google Voice on a the web and other SmartPhones do not appear to be a problem: it does not 'replace' regular phone service or user interface on other access devices.

Of course, Apple may resolve the issue by saying that after more time to revue that they have worked things out with Google. That would be a result that falls short of what developers have said they would like to see, not just for the iPhone/Apple but also for all mobile device open development efforts: clear requirements guidelines and transparent qualification process that reduces their degree of risk and improves their knowledge of opportunities.

Much more hangs in the balance than whether this single application runs on a currently popular mobile device:

The Obama administration is broadly considered to favor more open access and competition among suppliers and operators. Advisers who now work for the administration had been known previously to have favored a more aggressive stance on FCC decisions including the wholesale access provisions for the C-Block 700MHz auction.

What Apple has done is punted to avoid the FCC coming down with a decision which would set precedence for the future. Apple would rather say "What problem? These things take time. And it isn't that we object to competition from alternative voice and other applications, it is that Google is messing with the interface so they might bruise our Apple."

The issue goes far beyond Apple to how open and transparent and fair the qualification process is for open development platforms and apps store placement. This is an ongoing issue that stems from evolution of the supply ecosystem of the broadband wireless Cloud. This has ramifications for all other operators in the U.S. and can influence regulations and commercial development internationally. To a large extent the commercial trends push for the innovation open development unleashes and attempts to confine it are likely to eventually backfire. In the near term Apple hopes to hold onto the role as surrogate for operator control of the walled garden, a position that has become less viable for mobile operators, handset and integrated network suppliers.

If the FCC requires Apple to admit applications where will it end? Apple and other apps stores and device manufacturers restrict applications that are packaged to be available for specific OS and devices used on mobile networks. Would the ruling result in a flood of appeals to the FCC for similar action or will a higher degree of visibility into the selection criteria and process for 'open' apps dev.

In the long run we think commercial forces will pressure increased openness because open development is the engine that will drive subscriber loyalty through greater choice and innovation. But the industry is structured around simple voice, messaging that has the inevitable sway to retain control.

Labels: , , , , ,